Collection Retractable Brow Pencil - Waterproof Soft Charcoal

Unfortunately this really isn't grey or charcoal. It's like a muddy brown. I have grey and brown hair (that actually looks blond) so I like to mix a dark brown eyebrow pencil and a grey/silver. The first grey eyebrow pencil I ever purchased was discontinued. The next one was so light grey it looked blue and I felt like Grandma Smurf. It was tricky to mix that bluish gray product with the brown. The grey product I ordered instead of the Sephora is this one -> ROZO Long lasting and Waterproof Professional Makeup Auto Eyebrow Pencil (NO.4 Natural Gray). The color is PERFECT! Only thing is the width of the crayon part is wide so if you're trying to get a fine line it's tough. Luckily the Loreal dark brown I put on first has a finer width crayon so I can define the brow shape. Then I lightly color over that with the ROZO Gray product. Together that's a good combo.

I like the charcoal color!! The fine pencil is great for creating hair & the fine brush is super for softening the brows!

This is a favorite of mine use it everyday

The best eyebrow pencil I have found so far.

My favorite eyebrow pencil. Lasts a long time.

One of the best brow pencils I have ever bought

great!

One of the few brow pencils I've found that works for girls with black eyebrows! Love it and buy it repeatedly every time I run out. Goes on easily and looks natural. Stays on all day without touch ups. I have nothing but good things to say about it!