e.l.f. Liquid Eyeliner, High-pigment Liquid Eyeliner With Extra-Fine Brush Tip, Easy Glide Smudge-proof Formula, Jet Black

Why did you pick this product vs others?:I don't buy any other eyeliner anymore, and I don't think I ever will again. As an alternative girl I use A LOTTT of eyeliner, and this little bottle typically lasts me about 6-8 months, which is more than I would expect for its size/price and how often I use it. It doesn't smudge or get runny, it doesn't stain, the application is precise, it's very opaque, and its viscosity remains consistent. I have no complaints about this product!P.S. (Additionally, I am brown-skinned, and it still shows up on my skin tone perfectly, so if you have darker skin, it should work fine!)

This creates the perfect wing -- I have trouble with eyeliner in general and will sometimes go without but this is the brush is thin and glides on very smoothly. The pigment is perfect. I want to try this same item in different colors since it works so well. I prefer this over a stick or gel since you can control how thick/thin your lines are. I'm still practicing. Just be sure to let the lines dry before you open your eyes b/c it does take a few seconds to dry -- but I'm sure that's the case for most liners. I'm just a beginner so I don't know if that's typical or not. I love that two are in a pack and it'll last a while.

I’m really happy with this purchase. The product arrived on time and was exactly as described. The quality is excellent and it works perfectly for my needs.

Very pigmented, a little hard to use as the liner is so thin. Stays on well... unless it's a little hot out lol

This eyeliner has a consistency that is lighter than most others so it is easier to get a fine line. It is the best I have used.

Very high pigment , good texture , I like the size because I can just carry it in anything.

It works perfectly, and the most amazing thing is that is very affordable.

Overall this is a good eyeliner, last all day long. Only downside is that it stays wet for a while. If you look up it smudges on your top lid, so wait for it to dry fully before looking up