lilybyredSmiley Lip Blending Stick | Korean 3-in-1 Multi-Use Lip Liner, Smooth Creamy Texture, Long-Lasting Matte Finish, Soft Blur Effect, Precision Contour Pencil, 0.028 oz. (04 Giggle with Me)

Comparable to the Rhode blur lip liner, but a great subtle color that's nearly impossible to find in the US. On people with fair to medium skin, like mine, it creates a very believable shadow to make your lips appear fuller, especially under the bottom lip.The only drawback is, like Rhode, it's very creamy and so prone to wearing off. A very little setting powder on a small brush can help.

I LOVE THIS. Color is great and formula is smooth

Good quality

I actually REALLY loved this, purchased "Happy with Me" and its the perfect shade to outline my lips for contouring. Just as good as any high end brand at Sephora. I am light-medium skin tone and pigmented lips. I was going to buy another because the price point is SO good, but I just can't get past the smell! It's heavily fragranced (one star off) and its wafts up to my nose and I had to rub it all off my upper lip to get rid of the smell (like a rancid vanilla?). Longevity and texture are great though, long lasting and very smooth, no skipping or dragging. If they removed the fragrance, I would buy all shades!

So I did a test between the make up by Mario lip liner, and the lilybyred lip liner I would buy the lilybyred liner for it’s value and the fact that it’s very blendable

01 color is the most natural pinky muted mauve that isnt too light or dark. I dislike anything that turns orange or is too saturated and this color is literally the color of my lips. I have pale cool toned lips and nothing looks right until I tried this. The formula is nice and smooth without feeling heavyits not patchy or gummy an just right. Packaging is really good and feels expensive. Would repurchase. Worth every penny

Pretty color but tends to bunch up or flake if i use ‘too much’. It’s just not very buildable

I wanted to pair this with another product, followed a tiktok tutorial for my lips and I think the color is a bit too dark for me and always felt like it wasn’t really necessary in my lip routine. It is soft but the product runs quickly. Personally, I would probably get a lighter color if I had to buy it again but probably won’t. Isn’t smudge resistant, so it is very easy to remove. But I do like how it feels when I apply, I just don’t use it very often