COVERGIRL Get In Line Liquid Eyeliner, Black Crystal, 0.08 Fl Oz (packaging may vary)

This is the ONLY eyeliner I will ever wear. It’s good for precise application and my eyes are sensitive and watery due to allergies and it doesn’t move all day. It dries quickly and flakes off, it never runs. I’ve gone surfing with it and it has for the most part stayed on. You can take it off with just water, but water without rubbing does little to it. Color is gorgeous and it’s great for doing a pointed line on a hooded eye.

Normally I am a Sephora girlie, but there are a few items that just can not be beat by those "luxury" brands. This eyeliner is absolutely one of them.I used to use Urban Decay Perversion or something "edgy" like that, but when they discontinued it, I scrambled to try out a few different brands, and omg this dark horse galloped on ahead and became my Black Beauty (hahaha - I'm sorry, I couldn't help myself, I'll stop):- The wand tip is sharp and tiny, allowing precise lines, and it keeps it's shape as long as you are gentle/accurate about screwing the top back on (I have jammed it in a hurry so that's my own fault)- The actual eyeliner is a dark, dark black, none of that watery or gray ish. I get the matte one and yeah...it's matte, no shine or shimmer. It is so smooth and just glides on like it owns your eyelids.- It really does own your eyelids. The staying power on this is crazy, I've been messy before and fallen asleep with a full face on, woke up the next morning and it was basically still perfect. A little smudged but still THERE. It doesn't chip and sprinkle which is 1 of my biggest peeves with eye make up.- Although this isn't waterproof, it still holds up really well. I like that it is so easy to remove when you actually want to remove it.I've bought this eyeliner like 25× now, I've been using it for years and only now sat down to give it the praise it deserves. My boyfriend has heard our history (me & this eyeliner) and my sworn statements that "I will never EVER buy another eyeliner" enough times, so I'll just post that soliloquy here to give him a break...for now.

This product is the best eyeliner I have ever used. It goes on easily and lasts throughout the whole day. I have tried many brands over the years and this by far is the best, and it is not expensive. I highly recommend it.

I bought Black Vinyl since I had no idea which was the darkest. It definitely is very black and pigmented. This eyeliner is a liquid with a very thin brush applicator. The container is small and the brush is long. It applies easily and doesn't smear or flake. It lasts for ages on my lids as well. I wish it was waterproof. If it was, I would give it 5+ stars. I have had the eyeliner on for over 13 hours and it looks like I just applied it. I just ordered the crystal black shade which I assume has a bit of shimmer. I want the green shade too but can't tell if it is bright or deep. (I want a deep green). At any rate, for the low price, this Get in Line eyeliner is excellent.

I love this item. I was using a different liquid liner and part of my eye is more watery and the other liner would not cover it. This has no issue and smoothly goes on and comes off as needed. This is surely my go to now.

Stayed through though sweat and heat and didn’t melt!

Formula:This eyeliner has a ball inside the tube when shaking it up. The formula reminds me of Maybelline Stiletto, which I like! I prefer this type of formula over Revlon Colorstay Connect the Dots. Both Covergirl and Maybelline can flake off if I rub into them. If I don’t touch it, it lasts all day without smudging. It’s very easy to remove, hassle-free. I can remove it cleanly with just water and no raccoon eyes! When you want to draw a thin line, make sure to remove the excess liquid because this Covergirl applicator can get pretty wet and runny.Applicator:The applicator is probably the thinnest point I have tried so far. While it is impressively thin, it is too bendy/flexible for drawing wings and too thin for drawing throughout lids. Unfortunately, I won’t repurchase since it doesn’t suit my needs. It might have been perfect if it was firm. It seems like a felt tip but is it? I never used a brush tip before so I’m unsure.Other thoughts:Maybelline Stiletto is easier to fill in my lids but it’s a little thick to create a wing. I have to use 2-3 types of eyeliner to get a decent cat eye (I’m terrible, I know). I use NYX Curve Liner or Milani Eye Tech Perfection liquid liner to outline and “stamp” the wings. Those do not stay moist long so that’s where Covergirl was supposed to come in to fix it (but tip is too flexible).Products shown in photos:-CoverGirl Get in Line Liquid Eyeliner (320/Major Matte Black)-Milani Eye Tech Perfection Liquid Eyeliner-Revlon Colorstay Connect the Dots-Maybelline Line Stiletto Ultimate Precision Liquid Eyeliner

I love this eyeliner and how it stays on all day. And the brush makes the eyeliner go on smooth. Not bad for the price